Newcastle Banter Archive May 06 2013

 

Use our rumours form to send us newcastle transfer rumours.

06 May 2013 22:21:01
nufc worst managers top 5
5 ruud gullit didn't understand what nufc is about
4 sam allarrdyce would never be a success on tyneside with the trash his teams serve up.
3 alan pardew bad appointment negative football one good season followed by utter craap talks baalllaacks never wanted cheap skate appointment.
2 graeme souness yet another appointment the fans didn't want no personality crap football
1 kenny dalgleish the only manager at nufc to take over a team that was considered good and totally destroyed it led us to 2nd with kks team then stripped it to the bare bones sold ginola and ferdinand and replaced them with barnes and rush we went from formula 1 to scrap heap in one season.
my thoughts what do you think. del

Believable0 Unbelievable0

The sad thing is all these managers are recent, roeder and joke in here (joe kinnear) could have easily made the list, why us what have we done to deserve this craaaap.

Agree0 Disagree0

You hope, What you think is a not a true reflection. so if SAFC beat Southampton and we draw with QPR, will your comment be we will beat AFC and all the other results will be in our favour, we got beat off SAFC, LFC at home 9-0 and drew with West Brom and West Ham 2 teams with nothing to play for as many suggest, then we are going to beat QPR a team already down who only lost 1-0 to AFC, hope is the only thing that we have, I think, is based on blind loyality and is a waste of space and embarrasses any true fan who might just have a true understanding of the game. I feel for you at this time, get a job and be real

Agree0 Disagree0

Jack Charlton, Kevin Keegan, Rudd Gulit, Ozzy Ardiles and Willie McFaul.

Agree0 Disagree0

You can't include Keegan in that! Even in his second spell he wasn't in the worst 5 managers we've had. Catch yourself on!

Agree0 Disagree0

Keegan who lost a 12 point lead to Man U, Keegan who spat his dummy out when he couldn't spend yet more money, Keegan who dismantled the reserves, Keegan who had no idea how to handle the media, Keegan who has walked from every job when things go wrong! So what he got us playing good football, so did Sir Bobby and Keegan will never ever be or has been a good manager

Agree0 Disagree0

I can remember big jack was a good manager but like most clubs the fans didn't give him a chance.

Agree0 Disagree0

Keegan who took over when we were in the relegation zone of div 2 and kept us in the league, Keegan who the next season took us up as champions, Keegan who the next season led us to 3rd place in the PL, Keegan who took us closest to winning the league for god knows how long, Keegan who brought Andy Cole, Les Ferdinand and Alan Shearer to the club and had us playing exciting attacking football?

I know he's not perfect not least tactically but I have no time for anyone that could say he is in the worst 5 managers of this club.

Agree0 Disagree0

I miss Sir Bobby : (

Agree0 Disagree0

Keegan had some of the best players, not that hard to do when you had a chairman who threw money at players, remember Shearer being the record transfer fee at the time. All Keegan did was to do what Man City are doing now on a larger scale. The main difference is Mancini has won things, Keegan won. the first Division wow! With the players Keegan had we should have won loads of things in the early 90's, he messed it up. As for playing attacking football, i'm all for it, if you know how to defend as well. Keegan couldn't get that balance at any club or national team he apparently managed. It took Sir Bobby to get us back playing properly, I would have loved to have seen Sir Bobby have the money Keegan had to spend. Even Sir Alex knew that Sir Bobby was more of a man than Keegan

Agree0 Disagree0

Well I wish we had kk in charge it was a joy to go to the games with him in charge, the best football ever played by nufc in my life time. big jack was a good manager but his football style was a bit like big sams. but for me keegan was the greatest nufc manager and would have him back tomorrow, think any one dissing him should go and buy the entertainers dvd and enjoy nufc playing breath taking football

Agree0 Disagree0

Kks team
1 pavel
2 bez
3 watson
4 clark
5 peacock
6 howey
7 ginola
8 rob lee
9 sir les
10 beardsley
11 gillespie
this is keegans team you can add up how much it costs because it was worth it. think ginola was about 2m peacock 3m?ferdinand 6m bought with andy cole money. the rest wernt much or youth players who done good, barton was signed but steve watson and him shared right back, asprilla and batty were signed late on when the 12 point lead was already established, still every year teams spend loads of money in the pursuit of champions league places look at our final league positions under keegan if 4 teams qualified then, we would have been there almost every year, and playin great football to boot. del

Agree0 Disagree0

Jim Smith had us playing good football, but you don't go on about him. In fact with the resources at his disposal Jim Smith did a better job than Keegan. The person who we should hold in more regard than Keegan is Sir John Hall, he did more for the club than Keegan did on the pitch. The players Keegan had and the money he had to spend at the time should have equalled Championships and Fa cups, but we got nothing in return to show for it. Playing fancy football doesn't mean you win things. Keegan couldn't see that he needed to spend money and time on the defensive element of the game, he just wanted to score more goals than the other teams all the time. Man U beat us to that championship because they could defend and won games 1-0 on their run in. Keegan, lost the plot and blew it by trying to play mind games with Fergie. Sorry, Keegan was not good for Newcastle and wasted our best chance of winning trophies we have ever had in my 36 years of supporting Newcastle

Agree0 Disagree0

I'm 'going on' about Keegan because you brought him up.

So you're saying Newcastle's purple period in mid-90s was solely down to John Hall? He worked in a vacuum and the only thing that hindered him was Keegan.

Or do you think it would be fair to say that the manager of the club at that time had something to do with the rise. I mean you seem keen to attribute the fall to him.

Agree0 Disagree0

Keegan doesn't deserve the credit he gets. The original post said worst managers and its my view that given the funding and players Keegan was allowed to have by Sir John Hall he did not deliver anything for the club apart from fancy football. Any "good" manager would have got results, fact is Keegan didn't. Like I said before, in the 90's we were one of the highest spending clubs in Europe out spending Man U. Keegan failed in a epic way, and walked out because he wanted to spend even more money and Sir John rightly said no. Just because we finished 2nd to Man U doesn't mean he was a good manager. Sir Bobby achieved that with a less money and in higher standard premier league than the early days of the league when Keegan had the club. To quote a film Keegan was not the messiah, he was a very naughty boy.

Agree0 Disagree0

So are you saying that ANY manager could have had us finish 2nd in PL with that kind of spending by the board?

Agree0 Disagree0

Most average managers could have done that. Look at Man City, average manager, excellent players. {Ed023's Note - Mancini is far from an average manager}

Agree0 Disagree0

Hi ed, what would you class Mancini as? Look at the players he has at his disposal! Man City should be dominating not just EPL but Champions League as well, you can't tell me he has done a good job there. I don't really rate him. David Moyes is a far far better manager than Mancini could ever hope to be. {Ed023's Note - I thought his reign at Inter Milan was decent winning 3 titles on the spin but I do agree he hasn't been good as he should of been at City in Europe which me and Ed001 discussed earlier which he won!!!}

Agree0 Disagree0

Im not convinced about Mancini Ed, if he was that good why did Inter get rid? Also I guess I was judging him on his Man City management. I still think a better Manager at the time of Keegan would have achieved more. E. g. Bobby Robson i'm sure would have kept a 12 point advantage over Man U

Agree0 Disagree0

06 May 2013 22:02:38
I think sunderland will lose against southampton, we'll get a narrow win against QPR, wigan will beat swansea, we'll lose or draw to arsenal sunderland will lose to spurs, wigan will lose to arsenal, and beat villa. Sunderland to go down I think

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Sunderland just outplayed stoke with only ten men.

If they keep 11 players on the pitch and the crowd behind them roaring them on like against stoke they will beat Southampton I'm afraid.

Sunderland will finish on 41 points.

Agree0 Disagree0

I see Norwich going down with qpr & reading. Wigan will once again escape the clutches of relegation & I think Sunderland is safe (darn!). I got to believe well get something against qpr while I don't see Norwich picking up anything

Agree0 Disagree0

The worst team will go down the with no spirt of fight and playing with complacency. Ring any bells you don't have to look very far.
Ashley Llambias (how he is in football I will never know) and AP with a track record of relegation will ensure a trip to Boro next season.

Agree0 Disagree0

Wonderland and Wigan will still be in the PL next year as for us, weekend at Blackpool anyone?

Don't even try to defend a VERY terrible team.
The players don't care, not one of them looks in shape, they have had a bad year all year.

The only reason we signed any one in Jan was due to the fact that they all played in France and had to pay 70% tax on everything that they made. So why not come to Newcastle we'll pay you more.

They only came here for the money not because they wanted to come, not because the wanted to play for the club, and not because their friends were here too.

You can see it now, not one of them cares if we stay up or drop.

HBA will be at PSG when the seasons over
Cabaye will be going to PSG Arsenal Tottenham or Man U
Colo returning home
Cisse will be heading back to Germany

The rest of the team will stay, only reason is no one wants terrible players with no passion for their team.

Agree0 Disagree0

Oh my God! You're right and you've finally convinced me. I'm forgetting 40 years of being a mag and supporting someone else from next year. Come on Shrewsbury!

Agree0 Disagree0

06 May 2013 20:42:36
I think we should sign arouna Kone from Wigan, classy player with an eye for goal plus bags of pace which we could do with. If we could get him for under 4 mil would be great business

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Have you not been watching. We will not be signing any Premiership players when we are relegated which looks 80% sure.
Stop speculating we do not have the right Ashley saw to that.

Agree0 Disagree0

06 May 2013 19:03:53
Repost on team:
4-2-3-1
GK ELLIOT
DR DEBUCHY
DCR TAYLOR
DCL COLOCCINI
DL M'BIWA
DMR JONAS
DML TIOTE
RW BEN ARFA
AM CABAYE
LW GOUFFRAN
STC CISSE

Almost like last years six game winning streak but better, need to beat QPR so hopefully this will be enough.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

06 May 2013 19:01:42
Team for QPR:
4-2-3-1
GK KRUL
DR DEBUCHY
DCR TAYLOR
DCL COLOCCINI
DL M'BIWA
RDM JONAS
LDM TIOTE
RW BEN ARFA
AM CABAYE
LW GOUFFRAN
ST CISSE

almost identical to last seasons six game winning streak but its better quality, c'mon pardew get the team playing football and beat qpr so we can stay up.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Why Jonas? He offers nothing.

Agree0 Disagree0

06 May 2013 15:48:04
I just want to get this off my chest (This is considering we do stay up) A lot of people may completely miss the point on this or disagree with me or whatever, but I hope that some people do understand what I am going to say.

I was just watching live ford football special and they were analysing newcastles play and how they've gone wrong. Like for example in the derby, we had about 5 players in front of the ball, then all we had defending was our back four who were incredibly deep and tiote stranded in midfield and that's how we conceded the second goal. And they were talking about how direct we were, literally just launching it into the box with only 2 men inside the box and three around the edge, so all the opposition had to do was just clear it into the midfield, because there was such a big gap between the defence and midfield. Then they showed the game where we beat spurs 2-1, and in the first half, we were on the attack and the ball was by spurs's own corner flag, then assou ekotto cleared it out to the right wing where lennon was just alone, no one within 30 yards and he just had to run at the back 4 with bale and sigurdsson in support. Just as they cleared it to lennon they put the camera on pardew, and he was like "Oh my god, why aren't my defence pushing up, why aren't my midfielders sticking to their positions" he basically throw his arm across himself as if he was throwing a scrunched up bit of paper in the bin. Then it showed simpson on the ball in our own half, spurs pressing high up the pitch, and no one in support, there wasn't enough communication (and maybe its because we have a lot of french speakers, who can't really speak english properly) Ba and cisse were stranded up front with no support from the wide men, in fact ben arfa wasn't even playing right mid, he was having to take up all sorts of positions to create opportunities.

What I think the problem has been this season is not pardew, its the team not working together properly, not communicating properly, not playing properly. I can guarantee you pardew never gives them the tactic of hoof it up the field. Ba even came out and said "We always work mostly on possession in training" Players like williamson, simpson, ferguson, don't fit in to a possession playing team, they panic and just clear it or just hoof it without looking up.

Ok yes pardew has obviously struggled to find the right tactic and formation etc. this season, but that's because he hasn't been given those signings he wanted who were in his plans, so basically he probably had to draw up a new one from scratch with players like best, lovenkrands, guthrie all gone. A new plan that would be able to cope with europa league, a plan that just wasn't possible with the amount of injuries we picked up and the lack of fitness. I really don't think pardew is that stupid to say that we have a small team but still give them orders to play hoofball. There's obviously something not right in the coaching staff, he's already said he wants a new coach for whatever reason. But believe me, you cannot be an average or poor manager if you have led a team like newcastle who were average in 2011 to a fifth place finish in the premier league and come back from 4-0 down against arsenal to draw 4-4, to develop players like ben arfa, Ba, Krul, Santon, tiote into better players or top class players, to get us playing some great, silky football that we went on a 6 game winning run. this season was because of ashley and llambias they ruined it in the summer as a result we could not prepare properly and had to rush it and draw up a completely new plan that was probs not even a proper plan.

By december, that will be the time to judge pardew. in the summer, players like sissoko, mbiwa, haidara, debuchy and gouffran will be able to settle in easier, and speak a bit more english, and Pardew can draw up a whole new plan with little changes, have the support of mike ashley and derek llambias in the financial areas and try and lead us to a top 8, because we currently do have the squad to do that, (its just not performing up to standards)

Just give Pardew another chance people, I know that you struggle to find newcastle fans who still think pardew is the right man but we all loved him last season, and there's no reason why he can't lead us to another high flying finish next season with a fresh start.
But if we are relegated then that will obviously be the end of pardews newcastle career, but i'm confident we won't be.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Well said Alan

Agree0 Disagree0

To much to read.

Agree0 Disagree0

I agree mate, but at the moment we just need to focus on staying up

Agree0 Disagree0

Surely if the teams not working together then it's Pardews job to pick a team that can work together.

Agree0 Disagree0

Well with all the injuries he hasn't been able to pick a team that can play together very much.

Agree0 Disagree0

If he had a pair and demanded signings in the Summer instead of just being a yes man then the injuries wouldn't of had such an affect on us.

If we were struggling because of injuries why play our first team in the Europa league? The league should be a priority and then cup competitions.

Agree0 Disagree0

You don't know that he didn't demand more signings do you? The media don't pick up everything from behind closed doors!

Agree0 Disagree0

All he had to do is say we need three or four good signings when being interviewed to put pressure on Ashley.
Also didn't Pardew say our squad was strong enough at the start of the season? Yet we needed a CB, RB and a striker/winger.

Agree0 Disagree0

Even last year we played like the away side at home were lucky to get the 1st goal in games, still think we've had more good luck this season than bad. don't like starting games on back foot we are nufc ffs. pardew is clueless sack him sack him now. del

Agree0 Disagree0

06 May 2013 15:03:13
lads i'm seriously worried we are going down
i can't see us getting more than 1 point from
the last 2 games. at least when we went
down the last time we had a bit of fight in
us with barton, nolan, andy c. , if this team
goes down we won't be back for a long time,
or am I wrong

Believable0 Unbelievable0

You do realise sunderland have every chance of crumbling from the 6-1 loss to villa. I think pardew will fire them up for the qpr. We didn't concede against west ham which was very good and it was a goal from cisse. although qpr have nothing to play which could make them more dangerous I still have faith. stay positive HTL

Agree0 Disagree0

It didn't go over the line 0-0 correct result

Agree0 Disagree0

Colo has been the big miss since January. with him back in the team we look much better than we have done for weeks.

We need to win at QPR no ifs or buts, we need to put in a performance, they are down and out and have nothing to play for NOTHING and we have everything to play for.

Agree0 Disagree0

06 May 2013 14:21:06
"Martinez is very overrated. Everybody talks about his yearly saving act but who takes them down to the relegation zone in the first place?"

At the weekend Wigans most expensive player cost just £3m whereas we had Colo (9m), Cisse (9m), Yanga Mbiwa (6-7m), HBA (5.7m), Cabaye (4.7m), Tiote (3.5m) and a unused sub in Anita who cost 6.5m and yet we are three points above them.

Martinez does wonders with what he gets and gets his teams playing good football. Wigan are always going to struggle as they usually have to sell their best players for example over the last few seasons Valencia, Baines, Moses, N'zogbia and Palacios.

Martinez would be a massive improvement on Pardew but can't see Pardew leaving anytime soon.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Pardew can still do what he did last season even if we finish a few places below 5th. He'll have the summer to rebuild our team, get rid of all deadwood and redo tactics. Surely you can't expect january signings to settle in within a few weeks? Surely you can't expect pardew to give a team with some fresh faces to go out and play great football? Have faith man.

Agree0 Disagree0

It not about new signings settling, its the simple fact that Pardew has zero tactics and plays people out of position constantly. Add to the fact he simple won't drop Jonas.

Agree0 Disagree0

I agree get rid of dead wood starting with ashley, pardew and lambias

Agree0 Disagree0

06 May 2013 12:26:39
I think we will stay up as 15th place ahead of Norwich, Wigan relegated Sunderland and then already relegated QPR and Reading.
Then we need about £20million to spend on 4 or 5 good players.
Also get a bosman or two.
Sell a couple.
And most importantly get ride of Pardew replace with Rene Girard possibly.

In
Ideye £7m looks a top player
Austin £4m (he would be about £6m but only has one year left on his contract, I think)
Bautheac £4m
Ince Free
Douglas Free
Then an another full back for a few million. {Ed002's Note - Ince will not be available for free.}

Believable0 Unbelievable0

If sunderland lose tonight then I fancy them to go down SMB

Agree0 Disagree0

Even if sunderland lose they still have another winnable home game and I can see them winning one surely?.

Newcastle may not get another point qpr outplayed arsenal the other day and arsenal will need a win at sjp last game for top 4.

Agree0 Disagree0

Southampton are better than sunderland and will beat them. villa caused sunderland all sorts of problems in the air so I think they will be lucky to get a point against stoke. they will lose to bale

Agree0 Disagree0

06 May 2013 09:57:42
Right all I think we need is a minimum of two points to stay up. Wigan need a minimum of 5 points. Sunderland need a minimum of 4 points.
If we lose to qpr then we are almost down. If we draw, we'll be playing with fire (which we already are) and if we win then we will be safe. If we draw 1 and lose 1 then we will have to hugely rely on sunderland and wigan. If we draw both then we won't have to rely on them as much.
I think we'll beat qpr 1-0 then lose 2-0 to arsenal. 3pts for Newcastle
Stoke will come to sunderland fired up, in an aggressive mentality and I think they'll either draw or beat them 2-1. Then I think it will be the same situation for southampton. Southampton will either hammer sunderland or draw. Then bale will destroy them. 2pts for sunderland.
Wigan will beat swansea, win against villa and lose to arsenal 6pts for wigan.
I fancy sunderland to crumble and go down.
18th sunderland 39pts
17th wigan 41pts
16th Newcastle 41pts (gd)

Never the less, if we do stay up and ashley sticks with pardew, then I have every faith and confidence in pardew to rebuild, get some young decent and top class players in, give us a fresh start, with some plans over the summer for exciting and sexy football like last season, a plan a and b. If pardew can lead us to fifth then there's no reason why he can't do it again, even if it is still a 6th, 7th, 8th place finish it will be a huge achievement. Moyes had a great first season with Everton but then finished 17th. So he rebuilded and has turned everton into a top 8 club.

So let's get behind the team lads and we can stay up and have a fresh start. In pardew I trust (unless there are some people who still have faith with me)

Geordie Moses-HTL

Believable0 Unbelievable0

100% agree

Agree0 Disagree0

In your dreams, when! we beat stoke tonight your in the bottom tommorrow if wigan get a result, and if you do go into ythe bottom
you will not get out LOL, does your post make you feel better don't forget a draw puts us above you's as well you are fav do go down and there's no way any of you can say you are not, you won't get a result against QPR and defo nowt of Arsenal the toon are going doon FTM

Agree0 Disagree0

How do you work out that Newcastle need 2 pts and sunderland 4 if Newcastle do get their 2 pts then by goal difference sunderland would only need 3 learn your sums young man learn your sums

Agree0 Disagree0

To last post

its just assuming all the different things that could happen really mate.

geordie moses

we will stay up, can't wait for stoke to hammer sunderland

Agree0 Disagree0

Every week Geordie you predict everything wrong, bless you, look forward to your next post.

Agree0 Disagree0