25 Oct 2011 15:54:45
There is talk going round that Andy Carroll may be returning to Newcastle, loan + price guarantee in january ......... all depends on the price but I would love to see it
He's being linked to Spurs!
Whats your source? ed any news on this? {Ed001's Note - nope, just nonsense.}
Everyone is linked to spurs
To be honest part of me would love to see Caroll back in the black and white, however at the same time he's the one who handed in a transfer request and wanted to leave. Are we better off without him, propbably, but like I said part of me would love to see him sign for the toon for a cut price fee of like 10 mil (with them still owing us cash from the sale). But, then again i'd like to see someone like Rondon in his place.
Tbh no one really knows if he wanted to leave alot of the 'chat' was that he was forced out, there is no proof, however Carroll suited Toon play style because we got the ball into the box early.
True we don't know what happened, forced out or not.... but he no longer suits our style any longer or at least not the one we are trying to play. With players Cabaye, Marveaux and Ben Afra, we should be playing the ball more along the ground, not just hitting long balls into the box. We already have a ton of so called "big" Strikers, we need a more skilled and speedy striker. And if it were true (which i don't believe it is), i wouldn't pay anymore that 5m.
He is trouble......Believe me he is really "big trouble" and we got a brilliant deal out of this!
I cannot see us bringing him back, the board would not sanction this unless it is for peanuts and i mean 6/7 million
He's defo coming home coz we are better than the scousers and will be in the champions league next year
Was there not a text he sent a mate after transfer news broke that he was "gutted tho " printed in a daily paper. Still think he never wanted to leave toon ,and always looks a lost soul to me. But sadly dont think he would suit our play anymore ,not that any part of this rumour is true imo.
Lol loving the optimism ^ but the season is still young. plenty of games to go yet....
Tell me why on earth we should have him back? Probably on mega bucks at this point, he's a consistant drinker, and we have 3 strikers of his type already.
What we want is a technically gifted and pacey type. Carroll is neither.
We're better off without him lads, stop speculating, he'll never be seen in our shirt again.
Like I sad Rondon for me would be a better option, problem being he is valued at 12-20 mil.
Would love him back in a cut price deal. Still young and future England number 9. If he sorts his head out it would be a great signing
What a load of rubbish and I heard darren bent is coming back to sunderland.haha deluded geordies
Doubt we'd have him back... we have obviously moved on for the better
I was at beardsley talk in and he said carroll will be back? HE never wanted to leave NUFC did not want him to go but could not refuse the money. trust me he will be back!! he is so much better than best and ba
Better than best, Not better than Ba
Bent is coming back... Villa play there this weekend don't they? Hattrick on the cards there then!
And carroll will be back to put a few past you deluded geordies. go your pathetic, carroll has moved to a bigger club and is playing most weeks.
Playing most weeks, you know nout hes nothing but a bench warmer at liverpool had gerrard been fit he wouldnt be getting a sniff