Newcastle Banter Archive January 20 2013

 

Use our rumours form to send us newcastle transfer rumours.

20 Jan 2013 23:12:43
pardew now 1/5 to be sacked bookies almost sure he's going, ill believe it when I see it

Believable2 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2013 22:53:38
id have the southampton manager who just been undeservedley sacked

Believable4 Unbelievable6

Good shout, he's a tactical manager who got southampton playing some really nice attacking football that completely tore us apart. Wouldn't mind him, martinez, blanc not sure bout Di matteo though.

Agree4 Disagree1

20 Jan 2013 22:49:17
we have a good team yeah if saylor is injured were short at ch as perch and williamson belong in the lower leagues, but apart from that our team looks strong, so what's the problem easy one to work out in my eyes. the problem then been fat mike does not know a good manager when he has one, let alone who would wanna work for him when you bear in mind the way he treated keegan, shearer and hughton, also how many managers would be happy at not been able to choose the players they sign, most of this done by g carr then youve gotta hope the fatman will stump up the relevent funds .

Believable1 Unbelievable1

Perch ain't a centre-back, he's a full back. Done as well as possibly can and give's 100%. Good to have in the squad.

Agree1 Disagree1

20 Jan 2013 22:42:43
THE BEST WAY TO GET THE TEAM PLAYING.....boo them makes sense NOT....like it or not we need to back the team and pardew for now

Believable2 Unbelievable7

Got a better idea of making our feelings known to pardew and ashley?.....

Agree6 Disagree0

The reading game was the 18th match of a shocking run.............the team have had every opportunity to sort things out, but havent. dnt blame the fans for the loss. the fans spend their had earned money to go to the games, they can bloody well boo if they want. think about those fans who travelled the 600 odd mile round trip to brighton!! they need to know how rubbish theyve been!

Agree4 Disagree0

I have an idea, lets bake them a cake and throw them a party.

The players just need a good pat on the back and thanked for their dire performances, that will be sure to remind them that losing is ok.

Agree1 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 22:33:24
Reports suggest that ashley would only have to pay a years wages to sack pardew, PLEASE JUST GET RID OF PARDEW NOW AND GET MBIWA AND BENT. top 4 managers would be happy with: 1. Laurent blanc 2. Martinez 3. Steve Clarke 4. Di matteo
We need an actual tactician, someone who can motivate the players and can come from behind to win a match and someone who can get the best out of average players. Not sure bout blanc coz him and HBA had a fall out if I recall, but martinez, Clarke would be fine, dunno bout Di matteo coz he's not the best at attacking tactics.

Believable3 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2013 22:11:36
we have a good team and most fans know what we need why doesn't the manager.1centre half, 2 if collocini leaves 1 left sided winger /striker.this would be enough to keep us up, don't see any point in bent he wants to play through the middle that position is already spoken for with cisse and shola as back up .mbiwa, dawson and siem de jong.

Believable0 Unbelievable1

20 Jan 2013 22:01:14
Pardew backed 1/2 for the sack.....Whats your thoughts Ed? I think if they going to do it, do it now and let a new coach bring in his own choices.....gut feeling he will get the boot, but not sure its the right thing to do now. {Ed001's Note - to be honest, having read the comments he made regarding the fans, it seems like he expects to get the boot and is already making excuses. Maybe I am being cynical, but to me it smacked of a man expecting to lose his job and saying 'it's not my fault'.}

Believable3 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2013 21:03:13
Sick of everyone getting on Pardews back all fans booing him 4 taking off cabaye he been injured for 2 half months for god sake and they expect him 2 run the full 90 mins yes I do feel marvoux sub was odd but for me the boo boys got on the teams back and cost us the game ! Please get behind the team pardew will be trying to bring players in but he can only do so much !

Believable1 Unbelievable8

What cost us the game was sitting back on a 1-0 lead.

Agree6 Disagree0

The boo boys reacted to a nonsensical decision by an inept tactician with a defeatist attitude(Marvs change) and nobody new cabaye was labouring when he got subbed.
They've got the right to express their feelings at Pardew because it's them that keep him in the lifestyle he is accustomed too.
The players are not daft except daft lad Ranger of course, and they will know what the boos were about.
Far the puppet to come out and say that post match is incredible. I wonder whether he actually understands the terms and words he uses in interviews. Bet he can't remember what he has said afterwards because his gob just seems to go into runaway mode.
Ashley must know that he has to spend a few quid to stave off relegation and I reckon he will. He knows he dropped a bollock last summer player recruitment wise and is still learning his role as an owner. As an owner he must learn when to act and now might be the time.
Right back to his puppet, Pardew has been doin this caper for a long time now with various clubs and he hasn't learned anything! His 2nd season stats at any club don't make good reading at all. If you think back, who was in favour of his appointment in the first place! Again, during his learning curve I hope Ashley doesn't repeat that mistake.
Laurent Blanc does sound appealing.

Agree3 Disagree0

If blanc came in hba would be gone ! Did they nt fall out when national manager !

Agree1 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 20:53:39
I was left aghast at the substitutions made by the man on a string yesterday, but once i'd learned of Cabaye twinge I could understand the 2nd change, but why didn't he bring on Obertan then(20mins left).
The 1st change, Marvs for Perch, was the main shocker for me. It looked like a knee jerk reaction to Reading bringing on Le Fondre. They took off Guthrie so were being less defensive and Marvs and Cabaye who was still on the pitch could of and should of exploited this. Trying to close out a game 1-0 with 25 mins left when the other team is throwing on attackers can only be proper wrong! This is a classic example of puppet boys tactical ineptitude for me.
Now, Pardew was harping on about the fans creating a negative atmosphere, but was it not him who issued negativity to a large audience with the Marvs substitution? Most post match reports say Marvs was ineffective yet he was the player who got us that free kick for Cabaye to put us 1 up!
There is also the question of why Jonas started the game as he's done nothing this season. I would rather have had Obertan on at start, at least he's shown glimmers of form recently.
I don't profess to be tactically adept but that Marvs substitution slapped me right in the kipper!
I personally believe puppet boy has been found wanting in the tactical department at this level quite a few times this season and a change is required. Had a dream last night that Pardew gets sacked the morn and i've been in joyous mood since I woke up this morning!
The hard part is the question of now or end of season.
Your thoughts are welcome fellow confused toon fans.
Some decent players being banded about on here.
An established centre half, creative mid/wide player and pacey/strong attacker would sort us right out.

Asleep yet?

Cheers,

Ash - c'mon the toon

Believable2 Unbelievable1

Pardew never gets us to try and kill off games. He's not a tactician like martinez or clarke.

Agree1 Disagree0

One of my favourite Newcastle memories will always be the image of Pardew having a bit of banter with Drogba on the sidelines after Cisse scored that wonder goal, I had grown to like his charisma but his results are terrible and we all knew this was coming based on the way we were playing badly but scraping results last season.

Pardew is now 15 for the sack, so the writing is on the wall.

I just hope Ashley does not go out and get the first Premier league manager available, there are some good coaches in Spain and German

Rijkaard is currently available and I think he would bring a fresh approach, one that we are in bad need off. Rijkaard would not be cheap but a good manager is worth his weight in gold.

Agree0 Disagree0

I think if we keep Pardew as manager we will most likely go down and I'm not sure if we'll come back up straight away like last time as a couple of Championship teams play better football than us and our better players will leave players like Cabaye, Ben Arfa, Debuchy, Santon. Anita, Krul and Tiote as they'll be trying to earn their place in their counties world cup squad.

However if we get a manager that plays passing football we improve our chances of staying up and we get to watch entertaining football and if we were to get relegated we'd have a platform to build on.
If there was any chance of it happening Blanc would be a great choice.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 19:54:57
Alan Pardew backed into 1/2 fav to be next manager sacked! Source

Believable1 Unbelievable1

20 Jan 2013 18:36:22
Im all for getting Darren Bent (he will score) or D Graham anyone to support Cisse we can not afford to play Ameobi anymore Destoon

Believable4 Unbelievable2

Bents a real good finish with pace as for danny graham I would take him to he would do a job for at least 3 years....k

Agree2 Disagree1

Darren Bent is an absolute DONKEY, doesn't give a flying toss about anyone but whoever signs his pay check. If he can't get into the Villa team then what in Christ's name can he do for us? If we sign him then all hope is lost.
Get Graham in, loves the Toon, gets goals, technically decent player - as shown by his performance against the Muckems.

Agree2 Disagree2

WONDERS IF BENT aren't IN THE VILLA TEAM DUE TO APPEARANCES as more appearences he makes the safc fee rise, s to 24 million...villa are f****d money wise does this make any sense edd?? {Ed001's Note - I believe it is more a personal issue than any money worries. Villa are not that skint, they just aren't getting investment from Lerner at the moment.}

Agree2 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 18:28:09
Alan Pardew is going to get fired soon

Believable2 Unbelievable2

If he does go l would like to see Gary Neville, yep!! Gary Neville heart on his sleeve type of person

Agree2 Disagree3

Gary wouldn't leave the England set up and his cushy Sky job to come to us, he's not daft.

Agree2 Disagree1

I would not be able to look at Gary Neville without thinking about Man Utd.

It would be too much for me to accept him as manager.

Agree1 Disagree0

No for christs sake

Agree1 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 18:14:21
Surely it's worth looking at athletic Bilbao and their players they are low down in the league and have creative players who are very good on the ball??

Believable4 Unbelievable0

20 Jan 2013 18:06:31
Serge Akakpo of togo would love to play in the prem is gd friend with Ben afra is only twenty five and wouldn't be to much to buy says it would be a dream to play in England these are the type of players that we should be wanting to bring in wants to come to England to play football not just for the money

Believable1 Unbelievable1

The ONLY reason any pro footballer would want to come to england to play is the money, the days of wearing your shirt with pride died when fergie started to dominate the epl. We are ALL living in the past.
liono74

Agree1 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 17:57:23
apparently we are favourites to sigh darren bent wow I bet that goes down well

Believable2 Unbelievable1

IMO it's more important we get a goal getter, regardless who previously played for ! Don't care anymore . He wil score, go for it .

Agree1 Disagree0

Its only football man!

Agree1 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 17:20:27
Considering the toon now have 12 days left in the transfer market and the next game is against the villa in 10 days its safe to say that we have to win that considering that the villa play two cup games within the 10 we have off and they only have 4 days to prepare for us fingers crossed someone gets injured for the game against us bent eke with a strain if some muscle would be a godsend . I would never wish an injury on anyone but with the confidence low results not going our way we need some luck and fast! I don't care where it comes from. And I am praying like a lot of toon fans if not all the s. Taylor is back and fit for that game!!

Believable1 Unbelievable1

Taylor v Benteke - oh no !

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 17:10:22
how is willo a pro. he's like a headless chicken walking around the field he's brutal... if you think asbout last season we got lucky how many times did krul get man of the match and us last ditch tackles and clearences off the lines. none of that this season.. the heart gone outa the team.... 4 signings by the wknd or were relegated...

Believable2 Unbelievable0

I said this at start of season willo poor also simo, it's not his fault ? Ap keeps picking him, there lies the problem !

Agree2 Disagree0

Safc pay about the same as nufc...even though you broke the bank for that party loving, skirt chasing ex city playing wannabee johnson..FACT..another fact is we pay make more profit than safc every year and ashley aren't stupid enough to but 21 year old players on 60k a week on 5 year contracts so dream on.....

Agree0 Disagree1

20 Jan 2013 17:02:16
We are now odds on favourites to sign Darren Bent.

Could do much worse! Get him or Graham in.

We need another creative midfielder in as well.

Believable2 Unbelievable3

You couldn't afford his wages, he left safc for more money and safc pay more wages than nufc and b£nt loves his money.

Agree2 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 17:01:39
I think finding a striker should be easier after yesterday's game rather then worse cabayes passing to cisse was world class at times and a striker with confidence would of lapped up some of them passes. Imagine a Gomis ect on the end of them. And who knows if we sign mbiwa he might be interested playing with 3 other French internationals. Surely mbiwa coming here and playing with Debuchy will increase his case to play for France.

Believable0 Unbelievable0

Cisse came close to taking some chances, cabaye and debuchy cross but good save from reading keeper.
he needs a few goals and next time those chances will be goals.

Agree2 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 16:25:09
According to we are favourites to land Darren Bent this month! Wonder what kind of reception he would get?

Believable1 Unbelievable2

Don't think we are in a position to moan about it ! If he scores who cares .

Agree0 Disagree1

Castoff

Agree0 Disagree0

Like, chopra, clarky, bramble and ANDY JOHNSON

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 15:57:12
even though I think fans pay there money and have a right to boo, we are in a dogfight now and could do with the full support of the fans for the rest of the season.
i don't like pardew he's not a good manager but for one ashley won't sack him so lets get behind him and judge him at the end of the season.
you never know if we stay up ashley might pack up his bags and move north, we can only hope

Believable3 Unbelievable0

Ashley has some big decisions to make. He put the management of NUFC in the hands of Llambias and Pardew, and they've obviously failed. Now, does he sack Llambias for failing to strengthen last summer (even Ashley thought we were going to sign a CB) or Pardew for lack of results? Or both? Does he give Llambias carte blanche to sign expensive recruits, or does he say sell before you buy? Does he have a new manager lined up? What would cost the most, relegation or sacking his management team? Does he throw good money after bad? (I don't know the answers, just the questions!)

Agree0 Disagree0

The reply has made a really good point, why are we targeting Pardew when the problem clearly lies with the management? Llambias has shown time and time again that he's a useless, classless, clueless fool and should not be the man representing our club. It's one thing having Ashley and Pardew in, but Llambias is about a thousand times worse - won't get the boot though, too chummy with the Fat Man.

Agree0 Disagree0

Thanks for the compliment (second reply) but Llambias can point to the signings he HAS made - Cabaye, Tiote, Ba, Cisse, Santon, Anita, Debuchy - all internationals (so obviously we don't pay peanuts, as some plonkers keep stating, as if they knew). The fault was entirely last summer's window. Apart from the well-known need to sign quality defenders, he also failed to plan for Ba's departure. Then was the time to sign a well-scouted up-and-coming understudy for the bench + Europa games. I can only guess that Charnley couldn't find the cash.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 15:55:55
Was at the game yesterday and the first half performance was exactly what we need! We have Ben Arfa to come back into the fold and create more chances and make the runs that Cabaye is looking for! We definitely need a pacey striker that can change a game in a run! Then the 2nd half begun and everything wrong with the team came to ahead! Willowtree reverted back to his disgraceful self and yet again Ameobi has stolen another days wages! (My god he's awful) BUT we need to stay positive, shocking decisions by Pardew but he did talk a little bit of sense, the negativity (although not shown to the players) did spread to the pitch and the weak players left on there who thrive on confidence just melted! We as fans need to try and give these players a lift, be the 12th man like we normally are!! I used to have a season ticket (but moved away) an I can't remember a times when the whole stadium sung! Lets hope for signings but ULTIMATELY lets MAKE SOME NOISE!

Believable1 Unbelievable1

Yeah it was the 1st sign of decent football all season shame about the 2nd half.
thought cisse got into some good positions and only a matter of time before he finds the goalden touch, again remember he aren't played in a central role all season.

Agree0 Disagree1

We were negative as soon as the second half begun we didn't attack and if I remember correctly Obertan had our only shot on target and that was in the 90th minute.
Although I agree booing doesn't help it was just another of the many excuses Pardew has.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 15:52:03
I think we should be looking in the Scandinavian market for players, their temperament is better and the prices will be nearer to what Ash will pay ?

Believable3 Unbelievable2

20 Jan 2013 14:41:58
Newcastle arrivals
loan -
Dawson - Spurs
Sinclair - Citah

Signings
Bent - Villa
Mbiwa - M'pellier
as well as Haidara and Gong/Thauvin

possible deals with Lyon loan or perm.
Yoann Gourcuff/Gomis perm
Alexandre Lacazette loan

and do it quickly please!!!
ShoutE

Believable1 Unbelievable4

20 Jan 2013 14:35:47
dont thing the answer is sack pardew tbh every one jumped to wrong comclusion yesterday at the game about cabaye but fact his he had a groin twinge....we really need 2 strikers danny greaham is one to be a good squad member for 3 to 4 years and another....possibly pull out the stops for sissoko and a centre back(the one we are chasing) and the another defender....williamson just is crap tbh and if colo wants to be away let him go I like colo but don't think you should every keep a player who wants away....cant see the signings above all coming but hey we can all wish......k

Believable4 Unbelievable2

Regardless if Cabeye had a niggle or not. He still took Marveux off and Anita. Who were both having better games than Jonas and Strolla. He is tactically inept and doesn't have a plan B.

Agree3 Disagree0

The thing that made the Cabeye sub infuriating was that he never thought ahead. Cabeye has been out for months was never likely to last full game. Why on earth did he take Marveux off before that we had no creativity with them gone. Shola and Jonas were appalling and I've always defended Jonas but what has happened to him? He should have taken one of them of if he wanted Perch on and played Marveux wide. To take Cabeye off and then put Bigi on when we were drawing was stupid. Why not put Obertan on then? Instead he waits another 10 mins and takes our best passer Anita off! Take Williamson off instead and move Perch back he would have got a big cheer on that one!

Agree1 Disagree0

Perch should always start ahead of Willo.

Agree2 Disagree0

He admitted he got it wrong taking marvaux off and think shola his past his best(not that he was that good) but he whares his heart where he should and his ok as last 25 minutes type player....jonas has not been the same player this season tbh.....k

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 14:18:47
It should have been evident in November when the injuries started piling up that we would needto do early transfer business in January.

Given we fractionally scraped past the worst time in the league at the time, QPR..... we then have the 4-3 loss at Man Utd, followed by the humiliation at Arsenal, losing at home to Everton, throw in the shambles at Brighton......well if then bigwigs at the club didn't realise that drastic action was required.....this should have given them a big wake up call..........but it didnt!

Now surprise surprise, here we are, two thirds the way through the window and we are in dire straits. We only had one plan.....Loic Remy......and we ruined that!

All the transfer 'rumours' speculate we are bidding for defenders....yes we need them, but strikers are what we need most.......one is not enough......we need two as a minimum.

Lose at Villa and I think its curtains for us!

Personally, i'd love Danny Graham, someone who can finish, that's what we need because Cisse isn't up to the job. Last season was a fluke for him, no doubt about it......he scored 'worldies' against Villa, Norwich, 2 at Chelsea........he'd never be able to do that again. Everytime I watch him i'm amazed how bad he is, a simple ball played to his feet ends up 10 yards away from him or somehow ending up in the air and he loses it every time.

I'm so disappointed, just wish someone at the club would speak to the fans and be honest in their appraisals of results and stop making excuses.

The fans have been far too understanding.....the boos are long overdue, we have every right to express our feelings!

Believable3 Unbelievable3

Seriously man, cisse was denied by 3 world class saves, and him and cabaye linked up fantastically. Give ya heed a shake man. When he starts scoring again you'll be first one saying class is permanent form is temporary.

Agree3 Disagree2

Cisse had a better strike rate than Ba in the bundasliga and was better in the latter half of last season than Ba .The lad has had all his confidence shattered because Pards buckled under pressure from Ba to go central again .He even admitted that at a charity event that Ba had caused alittle unrest with the team with his demands.

Agree1 Disagree1

Cisse has played in something like 27 games this season in all comps and scored 6......................now if uoure talking about class being permanent but form temporary....well I would prefer a centre forward who doesn't go thru FIVE MONTH.......yes FIVE MONTH temporary losses of form. Cisse is a jigsaw, sign 2 strikers and drop him.

Agree1 Disagree1

I agree with the first post; Cisse is not up to the job! his 'worldies' are a thing of the past!

Agree1 Disagree1

If you think Cisse is the man to get us out of trouble then you are as deluded as Alan Pardew!!

Agree1 Disagree2

Comparisons of Ba's and Cisse's strike rate in Germany is of no significance. How Cisse performs for Newcastle is what's important! in 6 goals in 27 (one of his backside against West Brom) is shocking form!

Agree0 Disagree1

For heavens sake the lad has been played out of position all season, yet still scored more from said position than the legendary demba ba when he was asked to do same thing. Cisse ain't the single answer to our problems no, but I believe he will have a big say in helping us stay up. Every single striker in the world will have a blip in form, just keep supporting him. Chin up lads haway

Agree2 Disagree0

Cisse is twice the player bent is he ll score loadsa goals playing in a central role, had chances yesterday but keeper had a blinder

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 14:17:02
Can anyone tell me why Nile Ranger hasn't been released yet? We don't need arrogant useless passionless wasters at the club.

Believable2 Unbelievable0

There was an element of truth in what he said but he's not in a position to say it, a respected team member would have got away with it, its about getting behind our team and stop picking on individuals no player tries to play badly even though they are clearly not premier league class.

Agree1 Disagree0

You can't 'release' a player when he's on a 3 year contract, Ranger is going nowhere and he knows it.

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 13:30:44
Pathetic pardew, blames the fans for losing and booing. Even ranger gets in on the act."Get behind the team, don't boo" NEWCASTLE UNITED DESERVE TO GET BOOED AT THE MOMENT, WE'VE HAD TO PUT UP WITH THIS LONGBALL CRAP FOR 5 MONTHS. Rangers a disgrace to thE Club. We've had to put up with being embarrassed to crap teams. GET OUT OF OUR CLUB GET OUT OF OUR CLUB, ALAN PARDEW, GET OUT OF OUR CLUB

Believable6 Unbelievable3

I agree with the long ball crap its just not the time to get rid of a manager now then spend a week getting a new one.....GET BEHIND THE TEAM AND MANAGER judge at end of season

Agree2 Disagree2

So your alright to put up wiv pardew with the risk of relegation?

Agree2 Disagree0

Sland fan here, so your finally admitting your a long ball team, phew its only took a year to admit it, pratdew doesn't have a plan be and he will get you relegated just like every club he's managed, he starts off well at every club then eventually implodes you have been warned.

Agree4 Disagree0

Yeah relegation usually follows a good season with him I posted this when he took over and reaally didn't want him as manager

Agree1 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 12:02:03
Masterful.
Team plays sh*te, blame fans for voicing their feelings and it was their fault Reading won.
Pardew not to blame in any way.
Players staing which teams they would like to play for.
Players wanting to go home.
Players choosing to go to bottom of table club rather than Toon.
Will ticket prices be less in Championship ?

Believable2 Unbelievable2

Pardews team now good players poor manager get rid

Agree0 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 11:56:25
Ed, would steve clarke be available, or can you not manage more than 2 clubs in a season. I'd like either steve clarke, martinez, maybe di matteo, but I saw wigan v sunderland and when they 3-2 down, they played some lovely football and deserved to win the game. Clarke is a miracle worker, he can motivate is team to come back. Plays some nice football on the counter attack. Ed, is there any talk behind the scenes that pardew is dangerously close to being sacked, and how much money would ashley have to pay to get pardew out, would it be 7 years wages or just 1 year? {Ed001's Note - there are no limits on the number of teams a manager can manage in a season, Clarke has only been at 1 this season anyway. There has been talk of Pardew getting punted, nothing really reliable but everyone thought the same regarding Adkins. I fail to see why on earth Clarke would want to leave West Brom right now though anyway.}

Believable5 Unbelievable1

I would love Steve Clarke at the Toon but can't see him leaving West Brom.... I'd even take Lee Clarke right now although ideally he would have a bit more experience first. One for the future maybe

Agree4 Disagree3

Wigan deserved to win ? Aye right - pressure and possession doesn't mean you deserve to win - goals my boy, it's goals that win matches otherwise Swansea would be champions of Europe ! And when you sell Mr Ba your goals dry up but you'll be fine so stop worrying - anyway, the Premiership needs teams like Newcastle, you know, yo yo clubs - it's what makes it exciting !

Agree4 Disagree2

Steve Clarke was at Newcastle for years as a coach and was not great.

He would basically be a coach again if he came back, with Ashley being Commander in chief of everything else.

Agree1 Disagree0

Yoyo club..? wonder which team has ben relegated the most from EPL..

Agree1 Disagree1

20 Jan 2013 11:55:42
HOW DARE YOU ALAN PARDEW. Sunday People today - Its all your fault Toon Fans. Negative attitude from fans put us on back foot. Absolute SHXTE. We lost yesterday because because the Team (YOUR TEAM AP) were not good enough, did not show enough bottle and can not defend. We have no options up front apart from an out of form Cisse and the big useless lump Shola Amadonkey who is only effective if he comes on for thelast 15 minutes when the opposition is tired and play at his pace. Our left side comprises a right footed defender who is reasonable going forward but can not defend and Jonas whose legs have gone and contributes nothing to the play apart from pantomime dives to win free kicks. AP stands there lih=ght a rabbit in the headlights, makes the wrong substitutions and then has the cheek to balme the long suffering, LOYAL but fed up fans.

Believable7 Unbelievable1

well said

Agree3 Disagree0

Look the fatman will not sack alan pardew yous where lucky last time yous went down that you kept all your good players this time around if and its a big if yous go down you will not keep the so called toon stars if I was a toon fan I would try and get behind your man because if yous go down you will have to build a new team that would be hard and come back in the same season don't think yous could do it

Agree2 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 10:12:28
Signing a left back to me indicates that Santon will be playing on the wing? he is far better than Jonas and can cross with either foot, good move if this is the plan. he seems more comfortable going forward and has the pace that jonas has lost to go past people.

Or, it could be that we are going to sell him, which does not bear thinking about as he has been one of our best perfomers this season.

Toonal

Believable5 Unbelievable0

Or it could be AP has realised Santon just can not defend. Another goal yesterday due to him allowing a ball to drop behind him an their winger putting in a dangerous cross

Agree3 Disagree1

Or he is leaving the sinking ship.

Agree3 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 09:38:28
i would give lee clark the job

Believable5 Unbelievable4

20 Jan 2013 09:02:28
If we sack pardew we only pay 1 seasons wages not all 8!

Believable3 Unbelievable1

20 Jan 2013 08:00:23
sacking pardew is not answer, getting some new faces through the door will do us the world of good. it's plain to see williamson is just not good enough to play every week, a striker is needed, a centre back is needed . if we can fill these positions with quality players then i'm sure we will be fine???

Believable6 Unbelievable4

Totally agree with this

Agree2 Disagree3

Nope, we've had to put up with this crap for 4 months now. Pardew is not a tactician, we need someone like roberto martinez, steve clark, roberto di matteo, not a puppet that simply plays long ball.

Agree5 Disagree2

Ever heard the expression a bad workman blames his tools.

While I agree Newcastle need additions the core of the squad we simply should be able to beat Reading at home.

If a Manager cannot get that right then it is the Managers position to take the fall for it, that is the whole point of what a Manager is, he controls team affairs and in return shoulders responsibility. If he wants to keep his job he has to get tactics right, motivate players etc... it is not happening.

How should a manager be judged if he is good enough or not is simple.

If a Manager has a better set of players than some other teams, and those other teams with weaker players beat that Managers team, well then that Manager is not good enough.

A good manager punches above his weight with his team, an average manager punches his weight, and a poor manager gets punched out by lightweights. Pardew is now officailly a middleweight getting punched around by the featherweights, that means it is time for him to go, he has lost the plot.

The cold hard truth of it is that Pardew will underachieve with good players and not get the best out of them, Anyone that states how good he was last season, take a look at the possession stats for the majority of our games last season, Pardew's football was always running a short lifespan because he was playing football that relied on luck and luck never lasts.

Agree3 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 00:12:42
Why are people saying fire Pardew and hire Di Mateo? He is an average manager who performed poorly in the league and played ugly, defensive football in the cups! He had so many great attacking players at his disposal yet he played defensive! I know most toon fans would be unhappy playing defensive as they enjoy attractive attacking football! Besides, the only reason Newcastle aren't performing of late is due to a huge injury list, which forces Pardew to play defensive as he is missing the flair and creativity if Ben Arfa and Cabaye, who I believe are Newcastle's best two players.
I do however agree that Williamson is awful, his defending for Le Fondre's first was woefull...

Believable5 Unbelievable4

Williamsons defended like that all year, we've lost so many points because of him, ie fulham, stoke, reading. Why is he even in our squad rather see perch at cb then him, my opinion we should release him no one is going to buy him. My heart drops every time the ball goes near him.

Agree4 Disagree0

I agree, plus I'm unsure why people would want Martinez, Wigan are consistently struggling season after season. i'm not sure sacking pardew at this stage is the answer (plus who would want to take the job?)
I was at the game yesterday and people (and press and even pardew) point out the fact that the fans were booing when cabaye was taken off (which is correct - I'd like to point out that I didn't boo even though I didn't agree at the tine as I think booing during the game is wrong coz it's only going to affect the players, boo at the end if you want to show your feelings) and I feel for pardew if cabaye was injured as it was hard to see that from the stands. However, no one seems to have mentioned that people were booing at the first sub which was marveux off and perch on after going 1.1 which WAS disappointing.
It was also disappointing to see shola on the right because its just reverting back to the Ba situation playing people out of position; even though I love Ba, I thought at least with him gone then pardew would at least be forced to play a winger out there. We are REALLY missing Ben Arfa but I'm afraid there might be too much to do when he is finally back.
Losing is a bad habit to crack or even just not winning....

Agree0 Disagree0

Get Robert Martinez for 3 reasons
1. He is apart from Sir Alex, Moyes, and Rafa the best manager in the league.
2. He plays nice football
3. He is used to relegation dog fights

Agree3 Disagree3

Williamson is tired, last year he did well as he had small run of games in the team then out again. he's tired he's making mistakes, need saylor back asap.
Although M'biwa salary looks like he's a replacement for Colo, looks like he's going, if not now then summer.

Agree1 Disagree0

Martinez turned down liverpool to stay at wigan so what makes you think he will join a club hurtling towards the championship?

Agree3 Disagree0

Had a chance in the summer to strengthen squad and didnt.
Was blaming injuries.
Now blames the fans.
Squad over performed last season and were lucky with injuries.
This season playing to their strengths and showing that they are woeful.
Same injuries that other teams suffer.
Best players leaving, no one worthy of mention arriving.
Total chaos.
Reading Wigan and Villa will finish above on current form.

Agree1 Disagree0

20 Jan 2013 17:20:58
i posted the 3rd post and noticed I have made a mistake, marveux was subbed at 1.0 but the rest of my comments remain!

Agree0 Disagree0